• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

Reporteev

News, reviews and more!

Ad example
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Film
  • Music

US Wine DtC Legal Battles—Time to Calm Down – wineindustryadvisor.com

October 19, 2021 by Wine

Advertisement

There are many reason for the Supreme Court not to hear a case—none of which the wine industry can influence.

—Jeff Siegel

Jay Hack, a senior partner at Gallet Dreyer & Berkey in New York City and the chair of the wine, spirits, and beer law committee for the New York State Bar Association, has a few words of wisdom for the wine business in the wake of last week’s legal disappointment. That’s when the Supreme Court declined to hear the Missouri retail direct shipping case, Sarasota Wine Market v. Schmitt – which might have opened up retail direct shipping across the country.

His advice? Stop getting so worked up about this stuff. It’s not good for your health.

“You’ll give yourself an ulcer if you worry about every direct shipping case,” says Hack, who predicted that the Supreme Court would decline to grant certiorari, the legal term for agreeing to review a lower court ruling (and known as cert for short). “There are many reasons for the Supreme Court not to hear a case, and they mostly have to do with the Supreme Court. Most of the reasons have nothing to do with the subject that you’re worried about, no matter how important you think it is.”

In other words, that so many people in the wine business were waiting with bated breath for the Supreme Court to finally decide whether retail direct shipping was legal didn’t make any difference to the justices. And it almost certainly won’t make any difference in the half dozen or so cases wending their way through the federal court system.

“Yeah, I think it’s pretty understandable to assume big things will happen when the Supreme Court gets involved, but in the end they’re always more selective than we’d wish,” says Alex Koral, regulatory general counsel at Sovos ShipCompliant, an SaaS/software solutions provider. “Ultimately, the industry will need legislative change to establish more expansive retailer DtC shipping permissions, even if the Supreme Court were to rule that states couldn’t discriminate against all out-of-state shippers.”

So, what caused so much optimism that ultimately wasn’t warranted?

First, the assumption that the Supreme Court’s decision in 2019’s Tennessee Wine Retailers meant more than it did and would lead to a favorable decision in Sarasota.

In Tennessee, the justices overturned a state law that said non-residents couldn’t get a retail liquor license. Justice Samuel Alito, in his majority opinion, implied that any state that was going to discriminate against an out-of-state retailer better have a damn good reason for doing so. In this case, there wasn’t one.

But, says Hack, what many may have lost sight of was that Tennessee Wine Retailers wasn’t as important a case as the 2005 Granholm decision, which legalized winery DtC shipping. Granholm made law; Tennessee just fleshed out the existing law surrounding the vastly complex legal workings that are the relationship between the so-called Dormant Commerce Clause of the Constitution’s 21st Amendment, and how all is interpreted.

And, as Koral noted, before the Supreme Court denied cert in Schmitt, the Tennessee ruling didn’t say there was anything wrong with the current system, in which each state decides how to regulate alcohol. It just said that the Tennessee residency law was unconstitutional.

Second, Sarasota seemed like a good opportunity for the court to finally settle the issue once and for all. But, says Koral, that was probably more wishful thinking: It “may be for the best that the Court didn’t choose to hear Sarasota; they might easily have come down in favor of the states’ ability to discriminate against out-of-state retailers, especially if they saw Sarasota as part of a developing pattern.”

He says that most federal circuit court decisions upheld the ban on retailer direct shipping, so there would be no reason for the Supreme Court to contradict the lower courts and overturn Sarasota.

So, no more getting worked up. Right?

_______________________________________________________________________

Jeff Siegel is an award-winning wine writer, as well as the co-founder and former president of Drink Local Wine, the first locavore wine movement. He has taught wine, beer, spirits, and beverage management at El Centro College and the Cordon Bleu in Dallas. He has written seven books, including “The Wine Curmudgeon’s Guide to Cheap Wine.”

Advertisement

Source: https://wineindustryadvisor.com/2021/10/18/us-dtc-legal-battles

Filed Under: Wine Tagged With: RSS Feeds

Primary Sidebar

More To See

npressfetimg-141.png

Snapchat’s new parental controls try to mimic real-life parenting, minus the hovering – WKNO FM

npressfetimg-140.png

HBO Max Making A Major Change To How It Releases Movies – Giant Freakin Robot

npressfetimg-139.png

The week’s best parenting advice: August 9, 2022 – The Week

npressfetimg-138.png

Abuse of VFX Artists Is Ruining the Movies – Gizmodo

Business

npressfetimg-1030.png

What’s next for the business of longevity? – The New York Times

npressfetimg-1017.png

Women in Business: Choices, sacrifices involved in running a business – Daily Record-News

npressfetimg-1012.png

Openings & Closings: Business news around the area – WFMZ Allentown

npressfetimg-999.png

BUSINESS BUZZ: Fatty C’s establishing itself within Big Rapids community – The Pioneer

More Posts from this Category

Technology

npressfetimg-11.png

Opinion | ‘Meatspace’? Technology Does Funny Things to Language – The New York Times

npressfetimg-9.png

Brian Coblitz Appointed Executive Director of GW Technology Commercialization Office – GW Today

npressfetimg-7.png

National taxpayer advocate directs IRS to implement scanning technology – Journal of Accountancy

npressfetimg-6.png

NCSS Technology Director Adam Phyall wins national award – Rockdale Newton Citizen

More Posts from this Category

Film

npressfetimg-134.png

Dane DiLiegro Stars in ‘Prey’ and Plays Monsters in Hollywood Movies – The New York Times

Los Angeles, like its signature art kind, is continuously evolving, b…….

npressfetimg-133.png

Unforgettable, legendary, timeless: Top 10 movies on IMDB | Daily Sabah – Daily Sabah

Among the best ways to kill time while at home is to see an excellent motion picture. Here are un…….

npressfetimg-131.png

The Bodies Bodies Bodies Cast Talk Favorite Horror Movies and Explain Gen Z – Rotten Tomatoes

The slasher flick has actually been a horror staple for so long that it’s challenging to …….

npressfetimg-129.png

Elvis movies: Can you answer these 22 questions about the rock King-turned-Hollywood star? – Commercial Appeal

Another “Elvis Week”– this one marking 45 years given that the death of Elvis…….

More Posts from this Category

Copyright © 2022 Reporteev